On a Tuesday afternoon at Confederation Park in Calgary, Stephen Carter outlines his expectations for the upcoming referendum on Alberta’s potential separation: he advocates for an 80/20 majority in favor of remaining part of Canada.
Carter expresses concern, stating, “If the results are close, we will be dealing with this issue indefinitely,” referring to the ongoing debate about Alberta’s independence.
“That would be the worst outcome.”
While at the park, Carter distributes lawn signs bearing the message “Stay in Canada.” He insists that individuals cannot simply take one item of campaign material.
“They must take two signs, brochures, and buttons, as each item serves as a prompt for conversation,” explains Carter.
A seasoned political strategist, Carter has collaborated with various Alberta politicians, including Naheed Nenshi, Alison Redford, and Danielle Smith.
Stephen Carter, affiliated with a group called Alberta’s Voice, expresses concern about voters potentially opting to stay home due to consistently low polls regarding separation. (Jennifer Chevalier/CBC)
However, this campaign poses unique challenges, and Carter is anxious.
“Albertans believe we will win by a landslide,” Carter comments. “So why would they take time away from their day, especially when it requires answering nine questions they know little about?”
Polling data has consistently indicated that a significant majority of Albertans prefer to remain in Canada, with only about 22 to 27 percent supporting the provincial government in initiating the legal steps necessary to conduct a second binding referendum on leaving the country.
This situation creates a troubling scenario for Carter and other federalist campaigns throughout Alberta: their backers may choose to stay home, thinking the outcome is predetermined. Additionally, they face highly motivated separatists who are actively investing time and money into their campaign and are hoping for low turnout from federalist supporters.
John Ellard, a social psychologist who visited Carter’s setup, shared his concerns.
“I’m really worried we might experience a repeat of Brexit, where many people think ‘No, the polls indicate we will remain in Canada,'” Ellard remarked.
Carter noted that a significant challenge is the lack of data to identify where to concentrate his efforts.
“Historically, we have built capacity within our political system over the years, election after election,” Carter stated. “[But this time] we lack a historical framework … we have no means to reach out to the populace.”
WATCH | Calgary Chamber of Commerce says separation could cost province $62 billion:
Alberta could take $62B hit from separation: Calgary Chamber
June 24|
Duration
2:15
A report released Wednesday by the Calgary Chamber of Commerce claims Alberta’s separation from Canada could shrink the provincial economy by $62 billion a year. As CBC Calgary’s Joel Dryden reports, an Alberta independence advocate says the report plays on people’s fears instead of focusing on opportunity.
This absence of precedent presents a challenge for Janet Brown, a leading pollster in Alberta and the founder of Janet Brown Opinion Research.
Regardless of how often she surveys the public regarding separation, the findings remain consistent: around 25 percent would support independence, with a typical margin of error.
However, Brown informed CBC’s The House that an unbalanced voter turnout could complicate matters significantly.
“If we find ourselves in a situation where 100 percent of separatists participate in the vote, but only 50 percent of federalists do, then all this polling we’re conducting will be called into question,” Brown stated.
Motivated and engaged separatists
Approximately 150 kilometers north in Red Deer, Gerry Bennet sits at a table with a blue Alberta flag on one side and a Canadian flag on the other, awaiting the arrival of Keith Wilson, leader of the independence group Let Alberta Decide.
Bennet, a proponent of separation, believes that nothing Prime Minister Mark Carney or the federal government could say would sway his opinion. Reflecting on the future for his children and grandchildren, he becomes emotional during the interview.
“The cost of living is so high, everyday expenses are burdensome. Just surviving is challenging,” Bennet shared.
Gerry Bennet, a separatist from Red Deer, Alberta, encourages undecided voters to support the movement as a message to the federal government. (Jennifer Chevalier/CBC)
Although they represent a minority in Alberta, Bennet and his fellow separatists are highly motivated. According to data from Elections Alberta, registered third-party advertisers advocating for separation have raised nearly $925,000 to date.
In comparison, registered federalist organizations have accumulated $277,000.
Bennet advises undecided Albertans to vote in favor of initiating the process for a binding referendum, as they can still oppose separation later on.
“Send a message to Ottawa, and we’ll see where it leads from there,” urged Bennet.
Carter contends this is a risky wager that could result in a departure of businesses and industries uncomfortable with the uncertainty, reminiscent of the situation during the Quebec referendum in 1995. Several Alberta business leaders have recently echoed this sentiment.
“We don’t want to replicate that outcome,” Carter stated. “If you believe we would prosper by separating, you are mistaken.”
In a discussion with The House, Wilson minimized concerns regarding economic repercussions, asserting that Alberta possesses leverage over various provinces that could facilitate the establishment of its own markets.
Keith Wilson, leader of the independence group Let Alberta Decide, expresses confidence that the final phase of the campaign is crucial, dismissing low poll numbers for separatism. (Jennifer Chevalier/CBC)
‘We’re an energy superpower’
“A significant portion of British Columbia’s economic activity must move eastward to reach eastern markets, not just within Canada but also to places like Chicago,” he stated.
“We likely have more oil refineries than all the other provinces combined,” Wilson continued. “We are an energy superpower, and our products are sent to refineries in Ontario and even Quebec.”
When questioned about consistently low polling figures for separatist support, Wilson expressed indifference. He emphasized that the most critical period of any campaign is the final stretch, specifically the two weeks leading up to the vote on October 19.
“I jokingly say, ‘Yeah, we have no chance of winning. You don’t even need to vote. Just stay home, you’ve got this. Trust the polls, you’ve got this,'” Wilson said with a chuckle.
As the date of the vote approaches, Carter expresses confidence in an 80/20 vote split, acknowledging the long-standing sentiment for separation within the province.
Yet, that’s as far as he is willing to go.
“I firmly believe that we are better off as part of Canada, and the 80 percent of Albertans who share this belief represent the majority,” Carter asserts. “We should not be subject to the whims of a vocal minority.”