A man from Toronto, found guilty of two counts of second-degree murder for the shooting deaths of two young women at a house party in Fort Erie, Ontario, will face a 22-year prison sentence before he can apply for parole.
During the sentencing hearing on Monday in Welland, Superior Court Justice James Ramsay referenced rapper Christopher Lucas’s extensive history of violence and firearms offenses, the execution-style murder of one of the victims, and the profound effect the crimes have had on the families of the deceased.
Christine Crooks, 18, from Toronto, and Juliana Pannunzio, 20, from Windsor, were shot during a birthday celebration at a rented location on the Niagara Parkway in Fort Erie on January 19, 2021.
Lucas, known in the music world as El Plaga, was found guilty by a jury in January.
During the sentencing, family members shared their victim impact statements, expressing their sorrow over the loss of their loved ones.
The police inquiry faced significant challenges due to uncooperative witnesses; Ramsay indicated that 13 attendees at the party committed perjury to shield Lucas.
Dispute led to the first shooting
On Monday, the court learned that Lucas, who was romantically involved with Crooks, had a disagreement with her during the party and shot her in the hand using the Glock he had with him.
Ramsay mentioned that Crooks reportedly cried out for someone to call 911 before Lucas shot her two more times.
The judge suggested that Lucas was likely aware that Pannunzio, who was unfamiliar to most at the gathering, was the only person who might have called for help.
Crown attorney Jody Ostapiw stated during her submission that Lucas then approached Pannunzio, who was seated in the living room, and fired seven shots at her. Four bullets struck her in the head and neck, while the remaining three lodged in the wall just above her, depicting an “execution-style” murder, Ostapiw described.
Judge remarks on man’s ‘chilling disregard for life’
Ramsay noted that Crooks’s murder demonstrated how easily Lucas could resort to deadly violence.
The murder of Pannunzio, specifically, was described as “cold and calculated” by Ramsay.
“I find beyond a reasonable doubt that he acted this way because, as a stranger, he did not trust her not to report the shooting of Christine Crooks to the authorities,” he stated.
“This reflects a chilling indifference to life.”
In delivering the sentence, Ramsay acknowledged that Lucas, who immigrated to Canada from the Democratic Republic of Congo at the age of 10, was raised in a neighborhood plagued by gangs.
Ostapiw revealed that three of Lucas’s friends had been violently killed, and he himself had sustained a gunshot wound to the leg.
Evidence presented in court showed that Lucas had a history of violent and firearms-related offenses dating back to his teenage years, which continued into his adulthood.
“He has spent more than half of his adult life” incarcerated, Ostapiw stated.
A conviction for second-degree murder in Canada results in an automatic life sentence, but the decision regarding parole eligibility, ranging from 10 to 25 years, lies with the judge.
Lucas’s defense team requested that he be eligible for parole after 18 years.
Ostapiw urged Ramsay to make Lucas serve a minimum of 25 years before being considered for parole.
She conveyed to Ramsay that the residents of Niagara wished for him to condemn the influx of gun violence from Toronto into their region.
“We do not want it here,” she emphasized.
Ostapiw also pointed out that nine out of the 12 jurors in the murder trial recommended a 25-year imprisonment before parole eligibility, while the remaining three jurors refrained from making a suggestion.
Ramsay offered Lucas the chance to speak at the sentencing hearing, but he chose not to and displayed no emotion as he was escorted out of the courtroom.
‘Our grief is everlasting’: victim’s stepmother
Shellie Pannunzio, the stepmother of Juliana, opted not to comment to CBC News following the sentencing.
“It’s too overwhelming,” she remarked.
However, in her victim impact statement shared in court, Shellie expressed that her family would always be haunted by the moment detectives knocked on their door to inform them that Juliana, who had a passion for animals, had passed away.
“This has taken a toll on our family, our mental health, and our spirits. Our grief is everlasting. It is a pain I would not wish upon even my worst enemy.”
Mark Pannunzio, Juliana’s father, recounted how he was supposed to be “a hero, a protector, and a shield” for his daughter.
While she often sought his comfort from imaginary fears as a child, at that tragic party, “she encountered a monster that I could not protect her from,” he reflected.
He mourned the fact that he would never walk his daughter down the aisle at her wedding, and now only has an urn containing her ashes sitting on the dining room table.
“I realize that the urn and ashes are not truly my daughter, but they are all we have left,” he lamented.
“Nothing in this world feels the same without her.”
Gabriel, Juliana’s younger brother, expressed that he is tormented by the loss of his sister, with whom he used to cuddle while watching movies and enjoying popcorn.
“I carry this ache in my heart, and I am filled with anger that I never got to say goodbye to her,” he told the court.
Lisa Mulcaster, Juliana’s biological mother, shared that she is overwhelmed with grief, anger, isolation, and guilt.
“How did I fail to protect my child?” she questioned in court. “Guilt is a poison that erodes your soul until you become nothing more than a shadow of your former self.”
Mulcaster mentioned that she keeps some of her daughter’s clothing in a Ziploc bag so that on her birthday, she can open it and inhale her scent, and she continues to pay for Juliana’s cellphone service.
“I just can’t bring myself to cancel it.”
